All 16 movie Reviews

The Promise of Home The Promise of Home

Rated 3 / 5 stars

I'm seeing a pattern here...

I barely post reviews here on Newgrounds, but for this movie, I make an exception.

I liked your submission called Her and Mine 1001 wishes, but it had exactly the same flaws as this movie, notably the mediocre graphics, and especially the animation. You have a knack for influencing people emotionally, and you should definitely keep your focus there. The poor quality of the movie itself weakens the effect, reducing it to mediocrity.

One thing you should ditch is the pattern you seem to apply to your movies. You basically pick a song, play it twice, and show a slightly animated slide-show in the process. I noticed how you incorporated a running animation somewhere in the middle of the movie, it didn't look all that bad. If you just take a little more time and use this kind of animation thoughout most of your scenes, you could definitely make the whole thing easier to watch, and improve the storytelling.

The combination of on-screen dialogue and music works, but try and use two different songs, and don't let them determine the length of the movie. Get rid of the silence in the middle and try and use music without any lyrics.

I hope you find this review useful, and that it might help improve your next works. I'm definitely going to watch them.

People find this review helpful!


Rated 4 / 5 stars

Good screenplay!

I like this flash, but not because of the graphics. I think the graphics seriously lacked, but the awesome screenplay and sound made up for that. It's rare to see someone make a great flash with sub-par graphics, and that's why I comment.

The screenplay's alright, the sound's good too, what you need to work on is how to visualize it. If you can manage to pull that off, you'll sure have one awesome piece of flash. But heck, I gave this an 8. You're definitly heading the in right direction :]

Final Fantasy 8 Spoof Final Fantasy 8 Spoof

Rated 3 / 5 stars


Very original concept, but the execution lacks. The moving camara was very annoying and made it very hard to watch, especially during the fight scene with all the stats on screen.

Then again, the concept of having a life action FF fight is very orignial, hence I gave it a 6/10 (or 3/5). If you ever decide to make a sequal, try to put the camara on a tripod and add some sound effects.

Naruto: Harmonia -Redone! Naruto: Harmonia -Redone!

Rated 3.5 / 5 stars


You really have an eye for detail, except for maybe a few minor details, you almost re-created the outro (except for, of course, the characters). Just that deserves recognition ^^

Las aventuras de Mr.Coo Las aventuras de Mr.Coo

Rated 4.5 / 5 stars


Now THIS is what I call animation!

The Most Annoying Flash The Most Annoying Flash

Rated 3.5 / 5 stars

Sound needs work

The animation was kewl, the concept was good, but the sound was very, very bad. Mixing songs, throwing in random quotes at badly timed moments, it easy to listen to. Take it easy on the sound next time, don't mix too much.

Gandalf's 'Adventures' Gandalf's 'Adventures'

Rated 3 / 5 stars

Not bad at all

You say you're 13, right. Well, for something made by a 13-year old, this isn't half bad. Sure, it's not perfect, but it's much better than the standard issue stick movies that were made in less than the time needed to read the newspaper's front page.

The only thing that could use some improvement is the sound. The music is kewl, but it doen't really interact with the events. Also, though you did made voices, some sound effects would be nice.

Anyway, keep it up!

green-lotus responds:

Thank you for the good review,. I'll take your advice, along with many others, and improve the sound! I am glad you think that this is better than the standard stick movies that are submitted here. :P:P:P:P

Final Fantasy Day Care 2 Final Fantasy Day Care 2

Rated 4 / 5 stars

I like it when the red water comes out

I totally LOL'd during the Salad Fingers ref <]

Bushido - Episode 1 Bushido - Episode 1

Rated 3.5 / 5 stars

Needs voices, really

This movie desperately needs voices, which is a real shame because the rest looks promising. The sound was good, great music and nice graphics to boot.

Also, try to go easy on the motion tweens. Sometimes is looks a bit cheesy and not very dynamic, especially during the credits.

Anyway, you did good work and definately on the right path to very quality flash :]

Chain Reaction Chain Reaction

Rated 3 / 5 stars


Nice movie, a bit short, but good. The only suggestion I have for now is to have the screen scoll as the objects move, it gives that extra dynamic feeling that comes from chain reactions like this.

Right now, it waits for a few things to happens, and scrolls to "the next level". That was a downer.

freenrich-1 responds:

Yes i do agree. ive learned how to do a scripted camera so that would be easy but it would be too hard to change it now.